CREC Project News and Updates

State Small Business Credit Initiative: Lessons for Federal and State Programs to Support Business Capital Needs

October 13, 2016

Different types of programs are needed to meet the wide spectrum of business capital gaps.  The states have learned a lot of lessons over the past few years in which programs meet which gaps.  That’s a key takeaway that CREC and its partners at the U.S. Treasury Department and Cromwell Schmisseur learned from a new study of more than 140 business financing programs operated as part of the State Small Business Credit Initiative (SSBCI) during the past 5 years in the 56 states and territories.

The study, “Program Evaluation of the US Department of Treasury State Small Business Credit Initiative,” released in October 2016, represents the culmination of nearly four years of research and technical assistance involving hundreds of telephone interviews, dozens of site visits, and an analysis of nearly 17,000 SSBCI-supported loan and equity transactions.  SSBCI’s primary purpose is to get capital into the hands during and immediately after the financial crisis and to help jumpstart private sector lending by leveraging $1.45 billion in public funds made available by Congress as part of the Small Business Jobs Act of 2010.

The study found that the temporary program—expiring in 2017—had expended, by the end of 2015, well over $1 billion, or 72 percent of available funds to stimulate small business financing.  About 70 percent of the funds were used for lending and 30 percent for equity financing.  Combined, the state programs helped to leverage $8.4 billion in private capital thus far – an 8.15 leverage ratio, shy of its 10:1 goal, but well within sight given the ability of states to use recycled funding to continue making loans and investments to small businesses. Furthermore, 42 percent of the transactions were made to businesses located in low and moderate income census tracts – an unexpectedly high proportion given the need to get capital across many sectors.  Also surprisingly, the loans and investments went to primarily to very small firms – 80 percent of the transactions went to businesses with 10 or fewer employees.

For state leaders, however, the most impactful aspect of SSBCI may well have been the restored capacity that SSBCI provided to states.  SSBCI has been critical in helping states meet capital gaps when they had limited to no funding, and the program facilitated new program models designed to encourage cooperation among the states, the federal government, and private capital markets in delivering financing to firms.  In addition, SSBCI:

  • Helped states develop their local solutions to meet aspects of small business financing needs.
  • Offered technical assistance and build a network for knowledge sharing that did not previously exist.
  • Supported state efforts to determine their efforts might fill gaps in national programs offered by SBA, USDA, Treasury, and others agencies and adapt to unique challenges (e.g., falling collateral values, nonprofit financing needs, and gaps in private capital institutions or products).
  • Developed greater capacity within states to articulate and document capital needs, build stronger private sector relationships, and align program characteristics with market practices.

The report is available here or from the Treasury website.

About This Project

National Association of Development Organizations (NADO), EDD COP
Start Date: Jan 2023 — End Date: Apr 2027

CREC is partnering with the National Association of Development Organizations (NADO), University Economic Development Association (UEDA), National Association of Regional Councils (NARC), and First Nations Development Institute on a five-year effort to build and nurture the Economic Development District Community of Practice (EDD CoP).  Led by NADO, with support from the U.S. Economic Development Administration […]

Advanced Manufacturing Workforce Collaboration Network (ManTech)
Start Date: Jun 2023 — End Date: May 2024

CREC is partnering with E3 Analytics, Erys Consulting, Anthology Communications, American Manufacturing Communities Collaborative (AMCC), DoD’s Manufacturing Technology Program (ManTech), DoD’s Office of Local Defense Community Cooperation (OLDCC), and University of Kentucky Pigman College of Engineering to facilitate a collaboration network for supporting advanced manufacturing and building the future defense workforce. Through this project, CREC […]

The Hidden Innovation Infrastructure: Understanding the Economic Development Role of Technician Education in the Changing Future of Work
Start Date: Jan 2022 — End Date: May 2024

CREC senior staff advise the Rutgers research team at the Education and Employment Research Center as the team, led by Dr. Michelle Van Noy, seeks to understand the role of technician education in economic development, with a focus on manufacturing, technology, and innovation in regional economies.

New York State (NYS) Tax Incentives
Start Date: Jan 2023 — End Date: Jun 2023

The New York State Tax Incentive Project is an initiative to better understand the state’s business offerings, their effectiveness, and how they compare to other states’ programs. The initiative has selected 26 incentives programs that it wants to focus its research efforts on. CREC has been subcontracted to handle the third part of the request, […]

Inventory of Public and Private Sources of Education and Workforce Data
Start Date: Mar 2023 — End Date: May 2023

CREC created an inventory of public and private sources of education and workforce data to increase the capacity of the public Workforce and Labor Market Information System (WLMIS) to provide relevant data for education and training providers. The inventory considered a wide array of data sources that measure important WLMIS concepts, including: Households and People […]

Evaluation (GMKPI) Framework for NCBiotech and Accelerate NC
Start Date: Nov 2022 — End Date: Feb 2023

The Life Sciences Manufacturing Coalition collaborated with experts from the University of North Carolina-Chapel Hill, CREC, to develop an evaluation framework that ensured NCBiotech and key stakeholders were prepared to implement and evaluate projects funded by the Economic Development Administration Build Back Better Regional Challenge. These projects aimed to support innovation and impact, such as […]

New York State Advanced Industry Clusters Study
Start Date: Oct 2022 — End Date: Aug 2023

CREC is partnering with MRB Engineering, Architecture and Surveying, D.P.C. and other economic development experts to produce a comprehensive understanding of New York State’s advanced industry clusters, combining analyses of industry trends, workforce capabilities, and R&D and investment activity. Other team members include Syracuse University’s New York State Science and Technology Law Center (NYS STLC), […]

Non-Degree Credentials Research Network Staff Support
Start Date: Sep 2022 — End Date: May 2023

CREC collaborated with the George Washington Institute of Public Policy (GWIPP) on support for the Non-degree Credentials Research Network (NCRN), a project funded through a grant from Lumina Foundation. The NCRN is a multi-disciplinary community of scholars, practitioners and policymakers that focuses on the little-understood role of certificates, certifications, and other non-degree credentials in the […]

University Economic Development Association Staff Support
Start Date: Jan 2023 — End Date: Jun 2024

Since 1976, the University Economic Development Association has been working to bring together higher education institutions, private sector businesses, non-profits, government organizations, and community economic development stakeholders to create local and regional economic opportunity. UEDA, and its members, are leaders in advancing regional economic engagement fueled by higher education and represent those at the leading edge […]

California Centers of Excellence for Labor Market Research Training and Engagement Curriculum
Start Date: Dec 2021 — End Date: May 2022

CREC partnered with the California Centers of Excellence for Labor Market Research (CoE), the labor market information arm of the nation’s largest community college system, to redesign their statewide LMI training curriculum. The course resources developed provide instructors with a comprehensive, modular training library for equipping college leadership, faculty, and student-advisory staff with LMI regional […]

About the Client

Los Rios (CA) Community College District

The Los Rios Community College District is one of the nation’s most respected learning institutions and the second-largest community college district in California, serving the greater Sacramento region. We have four colleges, six education centers, and specialized workforce and economic development programs for local businesses, governments, and organizations.