CREC Project News and Updates

State Small Business Credit Initiative: Lessons for Federal and State Programs to Support Business Capital Needs

October 13, 2016

Different types of programs are needed to meet the wide spectrum of business capital gaps.  The states have learned a lot of lessons over the past few years in which programs meet which gaps.  That’s a key takeaway that CREC and its partners at the U.S. Treasury Department and Cromwell Schmisseur learned from a new study of more than 140 business financing programs operated as part of the State Small Business Credit Initiative (SSBCI) during the past 5 years in the 56 states and territories.

The study, “Program Evaluation of the US Department of Treasury State Small Business Credit Initiative,” released in October 2016, represents the culmination of nearly four years of research and technical assistance involving hundreds of telephone interviews, dozens of site visits, and an analysis of nearly 17,000 SSBCI-supported loan and equity transactions.  SSBCI’s primary purpose is to get capital into the hands during and immediately after the financial crisis and to help jumpstart private sector lending by leveraging $1.45 billion in public funds made available by Congress as part of the Small Business Jobs Act of 2010.

The study found that the temporary program—expiring in 2017—had expended, by the end of 2015, well over $1 billion, or 72 percent of available funds to stimulate small business financing.  About 70 percent of the funds were used for lending and 30 percent for equity financing.  Combined, the state programs helped to leverage $8.4 billion in private capital thus far – an 8.15 leverage ratio, shy of its 10:1 goal, but well within sight given the ability of states to use recycled funding to continue making loans and investments to small businesses. Furthermore, 42 percent of the transactions were made to businesses located in low and moderate income census tracts – an unexpectedly high proportion given the need to get capital across many sectors.  Also surprisingly, the loans and investments went to primarily to very small firms – 80 percent of the transactions went to businesses with 10 or fewer employees.

For state leaders, however, the most impactful aspect of SSBCI may well have been the restored capacity that SSBCI provided to states.  SSBCI has been critical in helping states meet capital gaps when they had limited to no funding, and the program facilitated new program models designed to encourage cooperation among the states, the federal government, and private capital markets in delivering financing to firms.  In addition, SSBCI:

  • Helped states develop their local solutions to meet aspects of small business financing needs.
  • Offered technical assistance and build a network for knowledge sharing that did not previously exist.
  • Supported state efforts to determine their efforts might fill gaps in national programs offered by SBA, USDA, Treasury, and others agencies and adapt to unique challenges (e.g., falling collateral values, nonprofit financing needs, and gaps in private capital institutions or products).
  • Developed greater capacity within states to articulate and document capital needs, build stronger private sector relationships, and align program characteristics with market practices.

The report is available here or from the Treasury website.

About This Project

Jobs and Employment Data Exchange (JEDx)
Start Date: Mar 2021 — End Date: May 2021

JEDx is an initiative to develop a public-private approach for collecting and using standards-based jobs and employment data. JEDx seeks to transform how job and employment data are organized, shared, and used to provide greater value to employers, workers/learners, government agencies, and others to improve the efficiency and equity of labor markets while protecting privacy. […]

Southwest Pennsylvania Defense Contracts Analysis
Start Date: Mar 2019 — End Date: Dec 2021

Given the rapid and ongoing changes within the defense industry, CREC is working with leaders in Southwest Pennsylvania to better understand the far-reaching assets, opportunities and impacts of its defense-related supply chains. Specifically, the CREC Team is conducting a defense contracts analysis and defense economy overview of the region’s defense industry. The research focuses on […]

DDAA Rural Broadband and EDA CARES Act Funding Peer Best Practices Research Report
Start Date: Oct 2020 — End Date: Mar 2021

The Development District Association of Appalachia contracted with CREC to gain insights about local development district efforts to improve their respective regions – specifically, to better understand local development district uses of CARES funding as well as to gain insights on best practices in promoting rural broadband.  The project will provide DDAA members with best […]

Early Childhood Education Pre-Apprenticeship Model Project
Start Date: Jan 2020 — End Date: Dec 2020

This report on the Early Childhood Education Pre-Apprenticeship Model was prepared for the 1199C Training and Upgrading Fund by the Center for Regional Economic Competitiveness and Center for Urban and Regional Studies at UNC-Chapel Hill with support from the Pennsylvania Key and the Pennsylvania Office of Child Development & Early Learning. Early childhood education (ECE) […]

Community Indicators Consortium
Start Date: Jan 2021 — End Date: Dec 2021

The Community Indicators Consortium (CIC) is a global network that supports efforts to use community data to improve quality of life. CIC provides resources and tools to help communities and practitioners advance the practice and effective use of community indicators. The includes increasing the use of indicators for monitoring community conditions and advancing sustainability, promoting […]

Texas Research Differentiation Report, 2021
Start Date: Jan 2021 — End Date: Jun 2021

CREC is working with the Austin Technology Incubator, Texas Foundation for Innovative Communities, The Academy of Medicine, Engineering & Science of Texas (TAMEST), and University of Texas at Austin to identify and document the state’s advantages in academic and applied research, including promising late-stage research relative to global innovation leaders. With this information, the project […]

Delta Workforce Program
Start Date: Jan 2021 — End Date: Oct 2021

The Delta Regional Authority’s Delta Workforce Program faces the dual challenge of developing new talent for the region’s leading industries while also supporting the retraining and reskilling of displaced and underutilized workers in distressed communities. With this Labor Market and Workforce Report, CREC aims to advance the Program’s goals of building a more prosperous Delta […]

Strategy Guidance Note on the Promotion of Public Sector Data Sharing
Start Date: Dec 2020 — End Date: Jan 2021

CREC developed a Strategy Guidance Note and related global case studies on data sharing as a principle of sound policymaking which can contribute to strengthening the effectiveness of institutions. The United Nations Committee of Experts on Public Administration (CEPA) has developed a set of principles of effective governance for sustainable development to provide practical, expert […]

Developing a Community Empowerment Scorecard
Start Date: Apr 2020 — End Date: Jul 2021

CREC is assisting the Colorado Workforce Development Council (CWDC) in promoting economic mobility among the individuals that are receiving employment assistance.  CREC is developing a community empowerment scorecard to help CWDC monitor the various factors that contribute to jobseeker mobility.  The scorecard will focus on examining career pathways and partnerships in the retail sector that […]

Assisting College Leaders In Using Labor Market Data to Drive Education and Training Curriculum
Start Date: Feb 2020 — End Date: Oct 2020

CREC worked with FTCC leadership and staff to translate data about labor market trends into more demand-driven curriculum plans that recognize key labor market opportunities as an important criterion in allocating limited college resources. Through this effort, CREC reviewed how FTCC used data in its curriculum planning process and facilitated working sessions with the Board, senior staff, […]